Smith machines and free weights are common strength training methods. Free weights involve using traditional equipment such as dumbbells, barbells, and weight plates, while a Smith machine is a fitness equipment consisting of a barbell fixed within a vertical frame. Many individuals wonder whether the Smith machine is better suited for beginners, being potentially easier to use compared to free weight equipment. In this article, we will carefully examine these two training methods, discussing their respective advantages and disadvantages. Whether you are an experienced weightlifter or just starting out, understanding the differences between these two training methods can help you make informed decisions when purchasing equipment and ensure that it aligns well with your training plan.
What Are Free Weights？
Free weights are a type of weight training equipment that lacks a fixed path or trajectory, requiring you to control the motion trajectory yourself.
-
Control and Stability
Free weights, like dumbbells, barbells, and weight plates, lack a fixed path or trajectory, requiring you to control the motion yourself. Stabilizing the object is key to maintaining control and recruiting more muscle fibers for increased strength and muscle mass.
-
Muscle Activation and Development
Full control throughout the movement is essential in free weight training. Stabilizing the object helps recruit more muscle fibers, enhancing both strength and muscle mass. This activation of synergistic muscles assists the primary muscles in movement.
-
Versatility and Benefits
Neutralization of free weights allows agonist muscles to perform movements within the desired plane, a significant benefit promoting substantial strength development.
What is a Smith machine?
A Smith machine is a fitness equipment consisting of a barbell fixed on a vertical frame that can slide up and down on two tracks, typically allowing vertical or near-vertical movement.
-
Features of Smith Machines
There are grooves on the tracks where you can hook the barbell. These grooves enable you to set the barbell at various heights and stop the downward movement when you feel the need to rest.
-
Functionality during Workouts
The Smith machine is positioned near a weight rack so that you can easily add weight plates and adjust the weight throughout your entire workout.
-
Muscle Engagement
The muscles trained through Smith machine exercises depend on the specific exercise you are performing. However, in general, the Smith machine directs the load force towards the prime mover muscles and away from the stabilizer muscles involved in the movement.
Let's discuss the advantages and disadvantages of two types of weight training so we can conclude which one is simpler.
Advantages of Free Weight Training
-
More effective for strength and muscle size gains
Firstly, free weights are more effective than machines for enhancing strength and muscle size. When using free weight equipment, you need to balance and stabilize the weight, engaging more muscles, especially during compound movements like squats and bench presses.
-
Easier to increase strength and coordination
Secondly, free weight training forces you to use muscles in a stabilizing manner. This can help enhance strength, explosiveness, and coordination through a movement. For exercisers with a good grasp of fitness knowledge, free weight training makes it easier to activate muscles and achieve excellent fitness results.
-
Flexibility and variety of motion
Thirdly, they allow movement in multiple directions, contributing to increased flexibility and range of motion. Free weight equipment offers a level of customization that machines cannot match. You can choose any type of weight (dumbbell, barbell, kettlebell, etc.) and any movement combination for each exercise, making it easy to create effective workouts tailored to your individual needs.
-
Budget-friendly
Fourthly, free weight equipment is typically cheaper and easier to place than Smith machines. This makes them an excellent choice for individuals with limited budgets.
Disadvantages of Free Weight Training
Challenges of Free Weight Training
Just as there are two sides to a coin, the freedom of free weights leads to increased injury rates. Free weight training requires a lot of balance, which can be challenging for some exercisers. If you struggle to maintain balance, you may need to lighten the weight or opt for machine-based strength training. Losing balance and dropping weights during exercises can result in self-injury or harm to others. Most injuries occur due to overestimating one's abilities, such as strength, leading to improper form and ultimately, injury.
Suitability and Progression
Free weight training is typically suited for those more experienced in strength training. Beginners should use machines to gain basic strength and conditioning before progressing to free weights.
Time and Safety Concerns with Weight Changes
Changing the weight of barbells and dumbbells can be time-consuming, and if they are not secured properly and slip during exercises, it can pose a danger.
Advantages of the Smith Machine
It's essential to understand that not everyone lifts weights to become a bodybuilder. Many of us incorporate weightlifting into our busy schedules to maintain muscle mass and physique. Machines have several advantages over free weight equipment.
Faster：
Machines offer quicker workouts. While bodybuilders may frequent specialized gyms daily, many individuals juggle between work, family, and other activities. Perhaps all you want is to "get in, work out, and get out." With a home all-in-one Smith machine, you can swiftly progress through your weight tasks without needing to rearrange or drag equipment. The Evolpow M2A equipment offers over 100 different strength training options, ensuring quick and convenient workouts without sacrificing your potential for strength gains.
Safer：
Perhaps the most significant advantage is safety. Machines inherently provide more safety during solo workouts. This is crucial because having a spotter doubles your chances of getting a workout in each day. Consistency, believe us, matters more than how much weight you lift on any given day. With the adjustable safety catches on each side of the Smith machine from Evolpow, you can trust that the barbell will never drop onto you. Stable muscles are crucial as the pressure on stabilizing joints increases when lifting heavier weights. For example, if you struggle with tricep presses due to a spot in the movement range that causes strain on your elbows, this limits the weight you can lift. However, using the Smith machine isolates the triceps without stressing your elbows, allowing for maximum tricep activation.
Easier to Use:
Machines require less stability and balance than free weight training, making certain exercises feel easier on the Smith machine because it stabilizes the barbell for you. As a lifter, your only focus is to push or pull while maintaining core support.
Ideal for Recovery:
Lastly, it's more suitable for individuals in recovery. Using the Smith machine, especially for those experiencing joint pain, particularly around the shoulders or knees, significantly reduces the risk of injury in those areas.
Disadvantages of the Smith Machine:
Potential for Overreliance, Neglecting Stability Training:
Our muscles are divided into two categories: superficial movement muscles and deep stabilizing muscles. Stabilizing muscles are crucial for our mobility, body control, and reducing the risk of injury. However, training on the Smith machine, with its guided track, can lead to a neglect of deep stabilizing muscles if the user fails to focus entirely on the exercise. Instead, they may only target superficial movement muscles.
Inability to Develop Proper Stability:
Many fitness novices, fearing free barbells before mastering squat movements, often trust the Smith machine more due to its guided track. They may experience a quicker progression in lifting heavier weights, leading to a false sense of achievement. However, this fear or trust is misguided. While it's true that free barbells can be dangerous without mastering squat movements, solely relying on the Smith machine isn't the solution either. What you should do instead is to master bodyweight squats and solidify proper movement patterns. Then, gradually incorporate lighter free weight equipment like dumbbells or kettlebells for resistance before transitioning to the Smith machine with incrementally increasing weights.
Conclusion:
The Smith machine is suitable for those seeking a quick and safe workout method amidst their busy lives. It offers speed, simplicity of operation, making it ideal for individuals needing to swiftly complete their training sessions. Additionally, the Smith machine is an excellent choice for rehabilitation, as it reduces the risk of injury. However, overreliance on the Smith machine may lead exercisers to neglect stability training. Therefore, if you aim to improve balance and stability, you may need to explore other training methods.
Free weight equipment, on the other hand, is more suitable for experienced individuals in strength training or those looking to increase muscle mass and recruit more muscle fibers. It offers the dual advantage of strength and muscle training while also enhancing flexibility and range of motion. However, using free weight equipment requires a higher level of technical proficiency and carries a higher risk of injury. Therefore, beginners may opt to start with machine-based strength training and gradually transition to free weight equipment.
FAQ
Q:Using weight machines is considered "lifting"?
A:Absolutely! As long as you get that making progress is key to changing your physique, you're good to go.
Pick exercises that suit your body shape and size on those machines. And remember, keep up with the whole 'progressive overload' thing - basically, just keep improving and pushing yourself to lift more or do extra reps. With that mindset, there's no reason why you shouldn't give those machines a try too!
Q: Do professional bodybuilders not use Smith machines?
A:No. There is absolutely tons of footage of great bodybuilders like Jay Cutler using the Smith machine. The practical experience of these tremendously successful people who are literally world class at what they do will always trump the theoretical whining of anti-Smith machine keyboard warriors.
Q:What are the most recommended exercises for the Smith machine?
A: The Smith Machine is beautiful for turning compound movements into isolation movements. Low incline press- Shoulder width grip, hands rotated outward so the middle fingers are pointed toward each other. Elbows out. Lower the bar to the collar bone.
References
https://www.anytimefitness.com/ccc/how-to/how-to-use-a-smith-machine-and-what-to-absolutely-avoid/
https://brigadoonfitness.com/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-training-with-free-weights/
https://www.garagegymreviews.com/smith-machine-vs-free-weights